Cyber insurance used to be a checkbox. Pay the premium, check a few boxes, get a policy. That era is over.
After several years of massive ransomware payouts, insurance carriers have tightened underwriting. Renewal questionnaires now read like security audits, and answers are increasingly verified, sometimes through external scans of your network. If your environment does not match what you attest to, the carrier can deny a claim.
What Carriers Now Require
Multi-Factor Authentication Everywhere
MFA on email is no longer enough. Carriers expect MFA on remote access (VPN, RDP), on privileged accounts, on cloud admin consoles, and on critical business applications.
Endpoint Detection and Response (EDR)
Traditional antivirus is insufficient. Carriers want behaviour-based EDR or MDR with 24/7 monitoring.
Tested, Air-Gapped Backups
Backups must be immutable or air-gapped (separated from the production network so ransomware cannot reach them) and tested with documented restoration drills.
Email Filtering and Authentication
SPF, DKIM, and DMARC properly configured; advanced threat protection on inbound mail; and DNS filtering on outbound traffic.
Security Awareness Training
Documented, ongoing training programs with simulated phishing tests and completion tracking.
Patch Management and Vulnerability Scanning
Critical patches deployed within a defined window (often 14-30 days) and regular external vulnerability scans.
What Is Different in Canada
Canadian businesses carry one more obligation that belongs in any insurance conversation. Since November 1, 2018, PIPEDA, Canada's federal private sector privacy law, has required organizations to report any breach of security safeguards that poses a real risk of significant harm to individuals to the Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada, and to notify the affected individuals, as soon as feasible. The rules apply to small businesses as well as large ones.
PIPEDA also requires you to keep a record of every breach, whether or not it has to be reported, for at least two years, and knowingly failing to report or notify can lead to financial penalties. An incident response plan that covers these steps, and breach records you can produce on request, are worth having in place before you fill in your next renewal questionnaire. See the Privacy Commissioner's guide to mandatory breach reporting.
The Documentation Problem
It is not enough to have these controls, you have to be able to prove them. Carriers ask for screenshots of admin consoles, sample reports, and policy documents. If a claim arises, they will request logs showing the control was active before the incident.
How We Help
Our Elite MDR managed service tier is built around what cyber insurance now requires: MFA, Managed Detection and Response with a Security Operations Centre (SOC), immutable backup, M365 backup, security training, and ongoing patching. We provide documentation suitable for insurance applications and renewals.
